Sometimes, things can sorta slip under the radar. Out of sight, out of mind you might say. So I thank one of my California contacts for bringing this to my attention. When I started covering high school sports in 1969, this sort of thing never entered my mind.
I'm speaking of an incident in Connecticut this past week, when during the State Open track and field championships, one person broke the State Open records for girls in both the 100- and 200-meter runs. That person is a biological boy. Terry Miller of Bulkeley, a transgender, won both events. In the 100-meter dash, the runner-up was Andraya Yearwood of Cromwell -- also a transgender.
The line from the theme song of the Archie Bunker show comes to mind -- "And you knew where you were then....goirls were goirls (loved that Archie accent!) and men were men". But, the time's they are a changin'.
I totally support those of the LGBTQ community. Athletes, non-athletes. Doesn't matter. It's your life, go for it.
That said, I think the whole Connecticut situation will call for some steps to clear up the muddy waters. The only solution I can see -- if an athlete is biologically male, then the athlete competes with the males. It's just not a level playing field if said transgender competes against females. It's just a fact of life.
For example, in the just completed WIAA State Track Meet, the winning time in the girls' Division 1 100 was 11.99 (and only 1 of 11 finishers was under 12.0) while the 200 time was 23.76 (again, the only sub-24.0 time turned in). For the boys, winning time was 10.65 in the 100 and 21.43 in the 200. In both events, all competitors were sub-11.0 and sub-22.0, respectively.
Hey, I don't have the answers here. Just want to get a dialogue going because sooner or later we will need to get to an answer that's fair for all. This isn't a red/blue topic or an across-the-aisle topic. It's a PEOPLE topic. And our families, friends, co-workers, neighbors...well, they all deserve a thoughtful, respectful approach.
I'm speaking of an incident in Connecticut this past week, when during the State Open track and field championships, one person broke the State Open records for girls in both the 100- and 200-meter runs. That person is a biological boy. Terry Miller of Bulkeley, a transgender, won both events. In the 100-meter dash, the runner-up was Andraya Yearwood of Cromwell -- also a transgender.
The line from the theme song of the Archie Bunker show comes to mind -- "And you knew where you were then....goirls were goirls (loved that Archie accent!) and men were men". But, the time's they are a changin'.
I totally support those of the LGBTQ community. Athletes, non-athletes. Doesn't matter. It's your life, go for it.
That said, I think the whole Connecticut situation will call for some steps to clear up the muddy waters. The only solution I can see -- if an athlete is biologically male, then the athlete competes with the males. It's just not a level playing field if said transgender competes against females. It's just a fact of life.
For example, in the just completed WIAA State Track Meet, the winning time in the girls' Division 1 100 was 11.99 (and only 1 of 11 finishers was under 12.0) while the 200 time was 23.76 (again, the only sub-24.0 time turned in). For the boys, winning time was 10.65 in the 100 and 21.43 in the 200. In both events, all competitors were sub-11.0 and sub-22.0, respectively.
Hey, I don't have the answers here. Just want to get a dialogue going because sooner or later we will need to get to an answer that's fair for all. This isn't a red/blue topic or an across-the-aisle topic. It's a PEOPLE topic. And our families, friends, co-workers, neighbors...well, they all deserve a thoughtful, respectful approach.
time
No comments:
Post a Comment